A new dimension has emerged in the ongoing conversation surrounding the acid attack on soprano singer Mary Claire, after Elizabeth Mokoro publicly responded to the actions taken by The Lighthouse Ministers Nairobi.

In a widely shared video message, Pst Mokoro addressed the group’s decision to suspend the alleged perpetrator, identified as Elvis, from all activities following the incident. While acknowledging the seriousness of the attack, she urged a response rooted not only in accountability but also in spiritual reflection and restoration.

Calling for a Christ-Centered Response

Mokoro emphasized that moments like these test the core values of faith communities, noting that beyond discipline, there is also a need to demonstrate grace.

“This is the best time to show this man Christ,” she said, calling on believers and ministry groups to extend compassion and guidance, even to individuals accused of grave wrongdoing.

Her remarks have since sparked intense debate across music and Christian circles.

“Both Parties Were Wrong” Remark Sparks Debate

In a statement that has drawn mixed reactions, Mokoro suggested that “both parties were wrong,” pointing to what she implied may have been underlying issues leading up to the tragic incident.

While she did not excuse the violence in any way, critics have expressed concern that such remarks could be interpreted as shifting focus away from the victim, who is currently recovering from severe injuries.

At the same time, Mokoro stressed the importance of standing firmly with Mary Claire, urging the public to show empathy and support.

“We must sympathize with the girl,” she added.

Group’s Decision Under Scrutiny

The Lighthouse Ministers Nairobi, a music group, had earlier released an official statement condemning the attack and announcing the immediate suspension of the accused individual pending investigations.

The group also distanced itself from the act and reaffirmed its commitment to uphold values of dignity and respect for human life.

However, Mokoro’s comments have introduced a broader conversation about how music groups and faith-based collectives navigate discipline, justice, and restoration in crisis situations.

Public Reaction Divided

Reactions to Mokoro’s message have been sharply divided. Some have supported her call for a balanced, Christ-like response that includes forgiveness and transformation. Others have strongly disagreed, arguing that the priority should remain on justice and protection for victims of gender-based violence.

The case has continued to spark national concern, highlighting the dangers faced by individuals attempting to leave toxic relationships and the urgent need for accountability.

A Broader Conversation

As investigations into the attack continue, Mokoro’s remarks have amplified an already complex discussion. It goes beyond a single incident and addresses how communities respond to violence, responsibility, and healing.

For many, the central tension remains clear. How can justice for Mary Claire be pursued while also responding with compassion and a call to redemption?

The conversation is ongoing, and the stakes remain deeply human.